Treat footwear as something you maintain. Soles, insoles, and uppers wear at different rates. Look for a comfortable fit and find out which worn parts can be replaced on the exact model you choose.
Should I choose boots or sandals?
Start with where you will wear them. Work boots offer coverage and a different sole structure; sandals suit casual warm-weather use. Compare the two work boots or the two sandals here as pairs, rather than treating all four as substitutes.
How much should I budget beyond the first pair?
Allow for the care appropriate to the material, replacement insoles or laces, and possible sole work. Ask a local repairer about the exact construction before relying on future repairs.
How We Choose BIFL Footwear
Footwear is BIFL when it can be resoled and uses quality materials that improve with age.